Two hours and 30 minutes into Bruce Norris’s “Downstate,” a TV in the corner of the Booth Theatre flickers with an episode of “The Smurfs.” The innocent blue characters are being chased by Gargamel, the evil, bald villain. It’s a strange, unsettling detail that feels out of place, until you realise it’s a deliberate signal from Norris. The men onstage, confined to a cramped Illinois apartment, are convicted sex offenders and pedophiles. The audience is made to confront the discomfort of watching characters who represent a taboo rarely addressed on Broadway.
“Downstate” opened Sunday night at the Booth Theatre, 222 West 45th Street, after an off-Broadway run at Playwrights Horizons four years ago that stirred controversy, much of it from people who hadn’t seen the play. Norris, who won a Tony for “Clybourne Park,” does not offer easy answers or moral lessons. Instead, he traps the audience in a claustrophobic space with these men, forcing a confrontation with their humanity and horror.
The play is set in “downstate” Illinois, the informal term for the area south of Chicago. Four men live together in a neglected apartment with peeling ceiling tiles and stained carpet. Their crimes vary in severity, and they are legally classified from level one (low risk) to level three (high risk). Fred, played by Francis Guinan, is an elderly man confined to a motor scooter. Dee, portrayed by K. Todd Freeman, is the outspoken realist and unofficial spokesman. Their ages and personalities initially incline the audience to like them, which Norris exploits to disturb viewers when their darker sides emerge.
The youngest two are Gio and Felix. Al’Jaleel McGhee plays Gio, a level one offender who had a relationship with a 17-year-old using a fake ID. Gio works at an office supply store and dreams of starting his own business, though the play suggests this is unlikely. His charm and smooth talk are on full display, but questions about his judgment linger, especially regarding his late-night interactions with a younger coworker, Effie (Ivy Wolk).
Felix, played by Adrian Martinez, is quiet and withdrawn, spending much of his time praying in his room. His soft-spoken nature contrasts sharply with the others but does not make him less complex. Liza Colón-Zayas plays their parole officer, Ivy, who initially seems harsh but reveals a rationality amid the chaos. Her confrontation with Felix in a scene marked by shame and fibbing is one of the play’s emotional peaks.
The tension escalates when Andy (Thomas Sadoski), one of Fred’s victims now in his 40s, arrives with his wife (Cassie Beck) seeking closure. Their visit turns volatile as the psychological damage inflicted on Andy becomes overwhelming. Sadoski’s portrayal of a man broken by trauma is raw and unrelenting, demanding emotional stamina to perform eight times a week.
Guinan and Freeman have been with these roles for some time, and their experience shows. Guinan, known from the original cast of “August: Osage County,” uses his kindly appearance to unsettle. Freeman, with intense focus, maintains a constant edge as he oscillates between hunter and hunted. Their performances are anchored in listening and responsiveness, qualities sometimes missing in today’s star-driven theater.
Joe Mantello directs “Downstate” with a brutal intensity. Each scene plays out like a cage match, leaving no moment of ease for the audience or performers. The play’s length and weight demand attention, but Norris’s writing offers no relief through easy catharsis.
“Downstate” confronts its audience without flinching. It refuses to let them off the hook or offer simple redemption for its characters. It is a rare Broadway production that forces a reckoning with some of society’s most uncomfortable realities.
According to NY POST.








