Skip to content
News

‘My family would kill me if they saw it’: the ‘harmless’ images that can be deadly for women in Pakistan

‘My family would kill me if they saw it’: the ‘harmless’ images that can be deadly for women in Pakistan

It was just a photo of a smiling girl in jeans and a vest top, taken at home. Nothing extraordinary for most, but for Maniza*, a teenager from a conservative town in Pakistan, the selfie risked triggering violence against her. “My family would kill me if they saw it,” she said.

Maniza has never left the house without her hijab. Her father opposed her attending school and warned her, “If I got into trouble, he would kill me.” He meant it. Her mother pushed for her education, but the threat of “honour” killing hung over her daily life.

This story is part of wider concerns about how images that seem harmless in one context can provoke deadly reactions in others. Tech companies are now urged to reconsider how they moderate photos online, especially those shared by women in countries where social codes and family expectations impose strict dress codes and behaviour.

In Pakistan, “honour” killings remain a grim reality. Women who break social norms by appearing unveiled or dressed in Western clothes risk violent reprisals from family members. The internet complicates this, making private moments public and exposing women to new dangers.

Maniza’s photo was a quiet act of rebellion but could have been enough to provoke fatal consequences. It is not confirmed whether she shared the photo online or if it was seen by someone in her community, but the fear alone is enough to silence young women.

Campaigners in Pakistan and internationally are calling on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok to adapt their photo-moderation policies. They argue that algorithms and moderators often fail to understand local contexts. What might be accepted as normal elsewhere can be interpreted as provocative or offensive in conservative areas, putting women at risk.

Tech companies have faced criticism for inconsistent moderation. Images of unveiled women or Western dress may be flagged or removed in some countries, but left unchecked in others. This inconsistency can endanger those whose families or communities react violently to what they see as breaches of social codes.

Maniza’s experience highlights the tension between personal freedom and cultural restrictions. Her father’s words were not just warnings; they reflected a reality where women’s bodies and choices can provoke fatal violence. This extends beyond Pakistan to other countries with similar social structures.

The issue raises difficult questions about how global platforms can respect local customs without enabling oppression or violence. Some activists want companies to develop region-specific moderation teams with cultural knowledge. Others call for more transparency about moderation decisions and appeals processes.

In the meantime, women like Maniza face impossible choices. To stay safe, they may have to hide their faces, their clothes, and their lives from the world. The fear of family violence can keep a girl from school, a woman from work, or a photo from ever seeing the light of day.

The challenge for tech companies is to protect freedom of expression without putting users in harm’s way. For Maniza and countless others, a simple photo is never harmless.


According to The Guardian.

Trending Now

Bandidos member Joel Leavitt testifies on CFMEU’s push for his construction job at royal commission News Bandidos member Joel Leavitt testifies on CFMEU’s push for his construction job at royal commission Costa Rican journalist Camilo Rodriguez shot dead amid rising drug violence, first killing in 25 years News Costa Rican journalist Camilo Rodriguez shot dead amid rising drug violence, first killing in 25 years US president arrives in Manila as Xi, Trump, and Putin prepare for trilateral talks on world peace at Apec and Asean summits News US president arrives in Manila as Xi, Trump, and Putin prepare for trilateral talks on world peace at Apec and Asean summits News Deer hunters face $750 penalty for violating baiting regulations in US state