Germany’s defence minister Boris Pistorius dismissed criticism from a US defence official about Ukraine’s strikes deep inside Russia as “quite a stupid thing,” after talks among Kyiv’s allies in Brussels this week.
The comments came following remarks by US undersecretary of defence Elbridge Colby, who said on Tuesday that “despite the public conversation focusing on the spectacle of deep strikes,” these attacks “have not been effective in driving an end to the war, nor do they contribute to blunting Russia’s advances on the frontline.” Colby’s remarks suggested scepticism about the military value of Ukraine’s long-range operations inside Russian territory.
Pistorius pushed back directly on this view. Speaking after the latest round of allied discussions, he rejected the US critique, implying that doubts over the impact of Ukraine’s deep strikes underestimated their significance. He called the US position “quite a stupid thing,” signalling a sharp divergence from Washington’s assessment.
Ukraine has increasingly conducted missile and drone attacks targeting military and logistical infrastructure far behind Russian lines. These strikes aim to disrupt Russia’s ability to sustain its offensive operations in eastern Ukraine. Kyiv’s leadership and supporting allies have often framed such attacks as necessary signals that Ukraine will respond forcefully to Russian aggression.
Colby’s comments came amid ongoing debate among NATO and Western officials about how best to support Ukraine’s war effort. While the US official conceded that public attention centres on Ukraine’s “spectacle” of deep strikes, he questioned their strategic effectiveness in ending the conflict or stopping Russian advances.
Pistorius’s reaction underscored Germany’s current stance, which appears more supportive of Ukraine’s offensive tactics. He reiterated a firm message towards Russia, saying: “I want the Russian Federation to receive a clear signal: for every strike they launch against our territory, we will respond twice or three times as forcefully. And we have the right to defend ourselves.”
The exchange signals tensions within Kyiv’s Western coalition over how to judge and back Ukraine’s military strategy. Germany, which has supplied significant military aid to Ukraine, has maintained a public position endorsing more robust counterattacks.
The talks in Brussels this week brought together defence ministers from Ukraine’s allies to discuss ongoing military and political support. Pistorius’s remarks came as the group sought consensus on next steps amid a war now entering its fourth year.
Colby’s scepticism about the deep strikes contrasts with Ukraine’s repeated assertions that such operations degrade Russian logistics, command centres, and morale, aiming to tilt the battlefield balance.
Pistorius’s blunt dismissal of the US view may complicate allied discussions on strategy and aid, revealing fractures over how to measure progress in what remains a grinding conflict.
The dispute over the value of Ukraine’s deep strikes comes as Kyiv continues to press its offensive in eastern and southern regions, with each side trying to gain ground before winter conditions worsen.
The debate also reflects broader questions about the war’s trajectory and what kinds of military pressure can force a resolution. For now, Germany’s defence minister has made clear his support for Ukraine’s approach and his rejection of doubts voiced by a senior US official.
According to The Guardian.







