Skip to content
News

Senior doctor key to Lucy Letby conviction was suspended from patient care during trial

Doctor whose evidence helped to convict Lucy Letby was barred from treating patients during trial

A senior doctor whose testimony was central to the conviction of Lucy Letby was suspended from patient care months before the trial ended. Prof Peter Hindmarsh, a specialist in pediatric hormones, was barred from treating patients by University College London Hospitals (UCLH) in March 2023. The jury was not informed of this during the proceedings.

Hindmarsh’s evidence underpinned the prosecution’s claim that Letby had injected insulin into intravenous fluid bags given to babies. The doctor’s expert opinion helped frame the argument that Letby caused harm by poisoning vulnerable infants.

The suspension came five months before the trial’s conclusion in August 2023. UCLH took the decision over concerns for patient safety, effectively removing Hindmarsh from clinical duties. No public explanation was given at the time, and the detail was not disclosed in court.

This information emerged in a Guardian investigation published this week. It reveals that while Hindmarsh was presented by prosecutors as a leading expert in the field, his clinical practice had been restricted well before his testimony ended. There is no indication the defence or prosecution raised the suspension with jurors.

Letby, a neonatal nurse, was found guilty of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder six others at a hospital in Liverpool between 2015 and 2016. The trial hinged on complex medical evidence, including analysis of insulin levels in the infants and fluid bags.

Hindmarsh’s role was to interpret hormone data and support the hypothesis that insulin had been deliberately introduced into the babies’ intravenous fluids. The prosecution leaned heavily on his assessments to argue that Letby was responsible for the unexplained insulin spikes.

The decision by UCLH to exclude Hindmarsh from patient care reportedly reflected concerns about his fitness to practise safely. Specific details of these concerns have not been made public. It remains unclear whether the suspension related directly to his clinical work or other issues.

Neither UCLH nor Hindmarsh have commented on the suspension. The hospital trust confirmed the restriction but declined to provide further details.

The revelation raises questions about the transparency of expert witness credentials in high-profile criminal trials. Legal experts have noted that disclosure of such facts is important for juries weighing medical testimony.

Lucy Letby’s case attracted intense media attention. The conviction followed a lengthy trial that examined the deaths and injuries of babies in neonatal care. The prosecution’s narrative relied in part on Hindmarsh’s expert opinions.

The absence of information about Hindmarsh’s suspension during the trial means jurors were unable to consider whether the doctor’s clinical standing affected the weight of his evidence.

This development adds a new layer to the scrutiny of the trial’s medical testimony. It also points to potential gaps in how expert qualifications and professional status are disclosed in court proceedings involving complex scientific evidence.


According to The Guardian.

Trending Now

Bandidos member Joel Leavitt testifies on CFMEU’s push for his construction job at royal commission News Bandidos member Joel Leavitt testifies on CFMEU’s push for his construction job at royal commission Senior doctor key to Lucy Letby conviction was suspended from patient care during trial News Senior doctor key to Lucy Letby conviction was suspended from patient care during trial US president arrives in Manila as Xi, Trump, and Putin prepare for trilateral talks on world peace at Apec and Asean summits News US president arrives in Manila as Xi, Trump, and Putin prepare for trilateral talks on world peace at Apec and Asean summits Costa Rican journalist Camilo Rodriguez shot dead amid rising drug violence, first killing in 25 years News Costa Rican journalist Camilo Rodriguez shot dead amid rising drug violence, first killing in 25 years